AUCTION COMMENCES IN:
Days
Hours
Minutes
AUCTION
Tuesday, January 20, 2026
11 AM EST
Location: On Site
Registration begins at 10 AM
Remote bidding available
Auction Without Reserve
January 20, 2026
11 AM EST • On Site
*This property is subject to pre-auction offers and/or direct sale prior to auction – Call 844.94.ELITE*
PROPERTY SPECIFICATIONS
Location & Overview
- .49-acre Gulf-to-Bay lot offering beach access and secure bay-side boat mooring
- Private boat dock for easy on-the-water access
- Recently listed at $6,850,000
- 6,041 total sqft
- 5 bedrooms and 9 bathrooms
- Mediterranean-style architecture
Main Residence
Designed by renowned architect George Merlin
Built in 2006 by Christner Brothers to the hurricane-resistant building code
Elevated on concrete-driven pilings for long-term structural integrity
Two interior gas fireplaces and one outdoor gas fireplace
Formal living, family, and sitting rooms
Elegant finishes throughout, including travertine flooring, tray ceilings, and crown molding
Five spacious en-suite bedrooms, each offering privacy and comfort
Kitchen & Dining
- Expansive gourmet kitchen
- Custom Yoder Brothers cabinetry
- Large space to host dinner parties
Additional Spaces
Dual private offices and a den
- Private theater room for immersive, at-home entertainment
Exterior & Grounds
- Private Gulf-front beach access
- Elevated, lagoon-style pool terrace with heated pool and spa
- Resort-like, lush tropical landscaping
- Outdoor fireplace ideal for evening entertaining
Location
- Casey Key is the secluded, ultra-exclusive counterpart to nearby Siesta Key – offering the same world-class coastline with an even greater sense of privacy.
- Home to some of the best beaches in the world, the island is known for its strikingly blue Gulf waters and pristine shoreline.
- Located mid–Casey Key, offering unmatched tranquility and seclusion.
- No high-rise hotels and minimal tourist traffic, preserving the island’s private, serene atmosphere.
- Ideally situated just south of Sarasota, the island is less than a 30-minute drive from Sarasota–Bradenton International Airport, making it both private and exceptionally accessible.
- Private beach access allows you to enjoy blissful afternoons on the powdery sands of a secluded 7-mile shoreline – just steps from the comfort and convenience of home.
Investment Potential
- Well-reviewed, highly occupied vacation home for short-term rentals.
- Rare Gulf-to-Bay configuration enhances long-term value and buyer demand
- Ideal for luxury personal use, income generation, or a hybrid ownership strategy
Auction Without Reserve
Designed by renowned architect George Merlin and expertly built in 2006 by Christner Brothers to rigorous hurricane-resistant standards, this exceptional Gulf-to-Bay estate embodies craftsmanship, strength, and timeless elegance. Elevated on concrete-driven pilings, the home offers peace of mind alongside refined architectural detail, creating a secure and enduring coastal retreat.
Begin each day with sunrise views over the Intracoastal Waterway from the deepwater boat dock and lift, and end it on your private sandy Gulf beach, where brilliant sunsets are nearly guaranteed. An elevated lagoon-style pool invites refreshing afternoon swims, while the heated spa and outdoor fireplace provide the perfect setting for cooler evenings spent under the stars.
Inside nearly 8,000 square feet, the residence offers five en-suite bedrooms and nine baths, complemented by formal living, family, and sitting rooms, dual private offices, a den, and a theater room. Elegant finishes abound, including crown molding, tray ceilings, travertine flooring, three fireplaces, and custom Yoder Brothers cabinetry. The expansive gourmet kitchen is ideal for hosting memorable dinner parties and gatherings with family and friends.
Set on exclusive Casey Key – where development is limited to single-family residences and commercial buildings are notably absent – this property offers rare privacy without sacrificing convenience. World-class golf, tennis, dining, arts, and cultural attractions await just minutes away in Venice and Sarasota, with easy access to private and commercial air travel.
This is gulf coastal luxury living at its most refined!
Auction Without Reserve
January 20th
This stunning property and the lifestyle that goes with it, will be sold at auction to the highest bidder on auction day!
Don’t miss out, register to bid today, and be ready to compete for the win…and it could all be yours!
1304 Casey Key Rd
Nokomis, FL
REGISTER TO BID
This property is subject to pre-auction offers and/or direct sale prior to auction. In cooperation with licensed real estate agent Valerie Dall’Acqua (Lic # 456512232, ph: 941.445.7295) with Sotheby’s International Realty. The auction services referred to herein are not available to residents of any state where prohibited by applicable state law. Elite Auctions, its agents and affiliates, broker partners, auctioneer, and sellers do not warrant or guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any information and shall have no liability for errors or omissions or inaccuracies under any circumstances in this or any other property listings or advertising, promotional or publicity statements and materials. This is not meant as a solicitation for listings. Brokers are protected and encouraged to participate. All bidders are required to pre-register for each property auction in accordance with the Terms and Conditions. Equal Housing Opportunity. With James Gall, Jr., a Florida-licensed auctioneer (#AU-2) and real estate broker (#BK300662) for Elite Auctions. Elite Auctions is a licensed Florida auction business (#AB3687) & licensed Florida real estate brokerage (#CQ1066803).
Get In Touch