16251 Shenandoah Cir, Fort Myers • FL


Tara McLean



Elite Auctions - Tara McLean


Preview by appointment only, please. Call or email us to schedule.


Wednesday, March 6th, 2024, at 11 AM local time

Location: On site

Registration begins at 9 AM
Remote bidding available

Broker Participation

Download Terms & Conditions

Elite Auctions Logo White

Auction Without Reserve • Wednesday, March 6, 2024, at 11 AM Local Time • On Site

*This property is subject to pre-auction offers and/or direct sale prior to auction – Call 844.94.ELITE*


  • Year built: 2005
  • Lot size: 1.01 acres
  • Zoning: AG-2 | Horses allowed
  • Approx. living area: 4,854 sq ft | Total area: 8,652
  • Attached 3-car garage | circular driveway | gated motor court
  • Levels: 2
  • 265-sq ft guest house/cabana adjacent to the pool | 1 bedroom | 1 full bathroom | outdoor kitchen
  • Bedrooms: 4+ office/den
  • Bathrooms: 5
  • Great views of the lake & fountain 
  • Located in Shenandoah, a 42-acre gated community of 21 1-acre+ lots | approximately 3 miles from Sanibel Causeway
  • Central lake & tennis court
  • Built by custom home home builder Mark Naumann
  • Courtyard-style layout | pool & spa are surrounded by ground floor living space

  • Gourmet kitchen | gas cooktop, double ovens, double dishwashers & wine cooler
  • Upstairs en-suite bedroom can be converted to suit
  • Bedroom & bath located adjacent to motor court
  • Impact-resistant doors & windows | whole-home generator
  • Located close to beaches, downtown shopping, dining & entertainment, recreation & parks, sports venues, golf courses, airport, and more
  • 3 miles from Sanibel Causeway

  • Deed restricted | HOA of $1k/quarterly

  • Central water/sewer/irrigation

  • **Known-damage sale**

Auction Without Reserve

Introducing 16251 Shenandoah Cir, a stunning 4,800+ sq ft estate in beautiful Fort Myers, FL.

Shenandoah is a 42-acre gated community near the Gulf beaches offering an extraordinary lifestyle. Consisting of 21 single-acre-sized lots and featuring a central lake and a tennis court, Shenandoah is zoned AG2, making it suitable for keeping horses. Homes here were built by custom builder Mark Naumann.

The primary residence has an exceptional lake view and includes a charming courtyard, with a pool and spa surrounded by the ground floor living space. Also included are two fireplaces, beautiful custom millwork, a gourmet kitchen with gas cooktop, double ovens and double dishwashers, as well as a whole home generator and impact-resistant doors and windows.

A stunning cabana / guest house with one bedroom and a full bath, along with an outdoor kitchen, is located adjacent to the pool.

The upstairs en-suite bedroom can be a theatre room or game room if you prefer. There is also an additional bedroom and bath off of the motor court. Lots of room for cars!

Nestled in the heart of Fort Myers, this stunning residence at 16251 Shenandoah Cir offers an unparalleled blend of modern elegance and timeless sophistication. Situated in the coveted neighborhood of Shenandoah, this property is a true haven, providing a peaceful retreat for those seeking both luxury and privacy.

As they approach this stunning property, residents and guests are immediately greeted by manicured landscaping and a meticulously-designed exterior. The curb appeal is enhanced by a grand entrance and a spacious, circular driveway leading to a gated motor court and three-car garage, providing ample parking space for family and friends.

Discover a meticulously-crafted interior that seamlessly combines contemporary design with classic elements. The open-concept living spaces are bathed in natural light, creating an inviting atmosphere. High ceilings and tasteful finishes contribute to the sense of grandeur, while large windows frame picturesque views of the surrounding landscape.

The gourmet kitchen is a chef’s delight, featuring state-of-the-art appliances including a gas cooktop, custom cabinetry, and a center island that serves as a focal point for both culinary creations and casual gatherings. The kitchen seamlessly flows into a spacious dining area, perfect for entertaining friends and family.

The master suite is a true sanctuary, offering a private retreat with generous space, a walk-in closet, and a spa-like en-suite bathroom. Additional bedrooms are equally well-appointed.

The fully-fenced backyard is large enough and zoned for  horses, while the delightful courtyard is an entertainer’s dream, featuring a sparkling swimming pool, a sun-soaked patio, and lush greenery that provides both beauty and privacy. Ideal for hosting a summer barbecue or enjoying a quiet evening under the stars, this outdoor space is designed for relaxation and enjoyment.

Convenience meets luxury in this prime Fort Myers location. Enjoy proximity to a range of amenities, including Gulf beaches, top-rated schools, shopping centers, dining, live sports, golf, recreational facilities, international airport, and more.

16251 Shenandoah Cir is more than just a property – it’s a lifestyle. For luxury property buyers searching for a home that seamlessly blends sophistication with comfort, this property and the upcoming auction together represent a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

Hurry, don’t miss out! Register today and be ready to bid live, in person, or remotely, on auction day…and it could all be yours!

16251 Shenandoah Cir, Fort Myers, FL 33908

Elite Auctions Logo White



Share this property with friends and family.

In cooperation with licensed real estate agent Stephen Petty (#488882, ph: 239-229-8913) with VIP Realty Group LLC (#VIPR01, ph: 239-403-7777). The auction services referred to herein are not available to residents of any state where prohibited by applicable state law. Elite Auctions, its agents and affiliates, broker partners, auctioneer, and sellers do not warrant or guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any information and shall have no liability for errors or omissions or inaccuracies under any circumstances in this or any other property listings or advertising, promotional or publicity statements and materials. This is not meant as a solicitation for listings. Brokers are protected and encouraged to participate. All bidders are required to pre-register for each property auction in accordance with the Terms and Conditions. Equal Housing Opportunity. In cooperation with James Gall, Jr., Florida-licensed auctioneer (#AU-2) and real estate broker (#BK300662) for Elite Auctions. Elite Auctions is a licensed Florida auction business (#AB3687) & licensed Florida real estate brokerage (#CQ1066803).